What counts as an emergency repair? A list for landlords
Ask ten landlords and you'll get ten lists. Most states don't define an emergency repair at all. Missouri's repair statute shortens its 14-day window "in case of an emergency" and never says what one is. [5] So it helps to borrow a list from someone who did write one down. Two good ones: HUD's inspection standard, and North Carolina's landlord-tenant statute.
Call now, don't wait for morning
- Gas smell, or a "rotten egg" smell
- Carbon monoxide alarm going off
- Fire, smoke, or a burning smell
- Sparks, exposed wires, or an outlet that's hot to the touch
- Burst pipe, water coming through a ceiling, flooding
- Sewage coming up through a drain
- No heat in cold weather
- An outside door or ground-floor window that won't lock, or a break-in
- A tree, car or collapse damaging the structure
That's the list Landlord Desk uses. It's a bit wider than the official lists below, on purpose: a false alarm costs you one phone call.
HUD's life-threatening list
For housing that takes HUD money, including vouchers, the owner has to correct a life-threatening deficiency within 24 hours of notice, and anything else within 30 days. [1] HUD's inspection checklist marks these as life-threatening, among others: [2]
- A natural gas, propane or oil leak
- A heating system that isn't working between October 1 and March 31, or an inside temperature below 64°F
- An exposed electrical conductor
- A blocked exit
- A damaged or missing gas shutoff valve
Two things on the same checklist are rated "Severe" and not life-threatening: no hot water, and a blocked sewage system. [2] Severe items get the 30-day clock. Most landlords would still treat sewage in the tub as a same-day job.
If you don't take vouchers, HUD's rules don't bind you. They're still a sensible yardstick, because a housing inspector or a judge will recognize them.
North Carolina's list
North Carolina is one of the few states that spells it out. Its statute calls these "imminently dangerous conditions" and requires the landlord to fix them "within a reasonable period of time based upon the severity of the condition": [3]
- Unsafe wiring, flooring or steps, ceilings or roofs, chimneys or flues
- No drinkable water
- Outside doors without working locks, and broken or unlockable ground-floor windows
- Heat that can't keep living areas at 65°F when it's 20°F outside, from November 1 to March 31
- No working toilet, or no working tub or shower
- Rats getting in through defects in the building
- Standing water, sewage or flooding from plumbing leaks or bad drainage
Gas: what the tenant should do first
Utility regulators all say the same thing: leave first, call second. The Missouri Public Service Commission warns, "Do not make a call from inside your house. Calling from a phone inside your home could create a spark that could cause an explosion." [4] Kansas adds that once you're safe, call the utility or 911, and don't go back in "until a gas company employee says it is ok." [6] Put that in the move-in sheet, in those words.
What can usually wait until morning
A dripping faucet, one dead outlet, a slow drain when there's a second bathroom, a dishwasher or dryer that quit, a closet door off its track. Tenants don't always see it that way, and a BiggerPockets thread from 2013 on after-hours requests is mostly landlords saying a lot of "emergencies" turn out not to be. [7] A written list given to tenants at move-in cuts down the 2 a.m. calls about the dishwasher.
This is a summary of public rules and guidance, not legal advice.
Sources
- [1] 24 CFR 982.404(a)(3) and 24 CFR 5.711(c), eCFR: https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-24/section-982.404
- [2] HUD, NSPIRE HCV/PBV Inspection Checklist: https://www.hud.gov/sites/dfiles/PIH/documents/NSPIRE_Checklist.pdf
- [3] North Carolina General Statutes 42-42(a)(8): https://www.ncleg.gov/EnactedLegislation/Statutes/PDF/BySection/Chapter_42/GS_42-42.pdf
- [4] Missouri Public Service Commission, Natural Gas consumer information: https://psc.mo.gov/CMSInternetData/ConsumerInformation/Natural%20Gas.pdf
- [5] Revised Statutes of Missouri 441.234: https://revisor.mo.gov/main/OneSection.aspx?section=441.234
- [6] Kansas Corporation Commission, Natural Gas Safety: https://www.kcc.ks.gov/natural-gas-pipeline-safety-liquid-pipeline/natural-gas-safety
- [7] BiggerPockets forum, After Hours Maintenance Request (2013): https://www.biggerpockets.com/forums/52/topics/96958-after-hours-maintenance-request